Rhamdao vs. Kermator (vtr_rk.xm)

Overall Impression (9/10)

Excellent piece of genre-defying composition. The composer combines orchestral strings with overdriven guitars and many different drums to create a really unique sound. Orchestral metal? Not really accurate, but the closest thing I could come up with. I was impressed right from the bold opening statement by the strings.

Technique, Arrangement, Composition (9/10)

Well arranged with little or no repetition of patterns. The song never gets boring. Samples are all solid, and the piece has a nice reverbed sound to it. Subtle use of effects -- nothing over the top. Instruments are enveloped for a pretty natural sound.

Development (7/10)

Perhaps a minor gripe, but I found that the themes in the piece weren't musically developed. It is a segmented piece. Therefore, I didn't hear much in the way of melodic development, so to speak. Still, I'm not sure that's what the composer had in mind. There's a lot going here in four minutes.

Creativity (10/10)

One of my favorite things about this particular module is the combination of sounds and feels. Therefore, I give it a high score on creativity. The composer makes good use of the advantages offered by computer composition, and doesn't worry much about whether the instruments would play together "live" so to speak. High marks here.

Enjoyment (9/10)

Due to the varied nature of the sounds in the piece, it is highly replayable. The combination of orchestral\metal guitar\and variable drum sounds and patterns mean that the ear doesn't get tired.

Additional Comment

Very interesting module. Arguably a little uneven, but it is well put together and I would certainly recommend a listen.