What Saga said, plus, chiptunes tend to get easier acceptance due to their small storage foot print, unlike huge, shitty, mega-sample based "newbie crap" (often song rips too) which we got lots and lots of. Those get binned. Oh gosh. So many.
Another thing is, since we now have accounts with people being able to rate modules compared to pre-2004, we have the ability for members to tell a user their module is good/shit by rating and comment. So eventually all the cream rises to the top, but we still like to give that a head start, hence the screening :-)
I think your EP idea is nice, but if anyone make a module which is irritating and with very little musical value (as Saga mentioned), yeah it might fall foul.
Since you've contacted us though I don't foresee an issue, unless Saga hates it so bad he mashes his keyboard and deletes the universe.