Mod Archive Forums

Website => Ripper / Plagiarism Reports => Topic started by: Psirius on February 16, 2020, 00:06:40

Title: User Janko Weber
Post by: Psirius on February 16, 2020, 00:06:40
Hello, yesterday I found this comment in "Memories of time":
Posted by Janko Weber on Fri 14th Feb 2020, rated 6/10.

Your stuff is never bad. But always I hear or see some
disharmonies and interferences in your songs.
Unlike other people I don't like the arrangement for
Memories of time and I think you should finish this song. ???
Some instruments sounds horrible for me.

I hear this in your song ...

memories_of_time-oarisch_aac-48kbps.aac (1.16 MB)

I replied kindly without believing that he was clearly the cause of uploading these link my xm.
Well, as I listen to removed channels and I do not know if something has changed, you can ... the uploads are in aac, and those pages do not say upload date or who ... I see the title respects it but my name artist, no ... in short, the license I usually put is that of Atribution Non-commercial Share Alike. I don't know what to do, I need some support, because I see that he is doing it to other artists. It does not create modules and has no favorites. I don't know what a type of person does here with I don't know what purpose ... Thank you!  :o
Title: Re: User Janko Weber
Post by: Saga Musix on February 16, 2020, 22:17:28
This is a bit of a difficult/weird case, but I wouldn't necessarily call it ripping / plagiarism as he always posts his edits as comments on the original tracks and never claims them as his own. But if you like, I can remove the comment on your track of course.
Title: Re: User Janko Weber
Post by: Psirius on February 16, 2020, 22:49:46
Hello again...! Yes, I know that it is not plagiarism or something similar, it was only knowing if this action was legal. About the comment, nothing happens. There is no disrespect and it seems normal. Thank you! ;)