171
Help Support Topics Archive / Re: Small QoL request: Show maximum allowed characters for artist comments
« on: April 20, 2021, 23:13:40 »
I'll look into this.
- May 06, 2024, 14:07:01
- Welcome, Guest
News:
Please note: Your main modarchive.org account will not work here, you must create a forum account to post on the forums.
Show Posts
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
172
Look what I made! / Re: My first full song, made with ProTracker 2.
« on: April 20, 2021, 20:05:34 »
As the track is currently in the "2nd opinion" queue, I will give you some feedback why that is the case and why it might get rejected in the end.
The track itself shows typical signs of being a firstie (which you just confirmed), and you should be aware that uploads to ModArchive are permanent. It's rarely a good idea to upload your first module, only very few artists are skilled enough that their first composition is actually listenable and that they themselves would enjoy listening to a month later.
In this particular case, the song has at least the following issues:
The track itself shows typical signs of being a firstie (which you just confirmed), and you should be aware that uploads to ModArchive are permanent. It's rarely a good idea to upload your first module, only very few artists are skilled enough that their first composition is actually listenable and that they themselves would enjoy listening to a month later.
In this particular case, the song has at least the following issues:
- The drums are out of sync. The drum loop is slightly shorter than 16 rows, so the loop is not in sync with the tempo at the end of the loop there is always a jarring bit of silence. Look into tempo command F to fix this.
- The song is essentially repeating three notes for almost two minutes before introducing a new concept. Yes, that doesn't necessarily need to be a bad thing, good musicians can get away with this (see example below). But especially when you are new to making music, it's very difficult to figure out why a minimalist techno track made by an experienced composer that uses just three notes can be worthwhile listening to but your own composition isn't. Typically that is because there is more to the song than just those three notes. This "extra fluff" can be subtleties like slowly changing filters over time (you do this over the course of less than a second, which gets very repetitive very quickly), or other changes in the sound (e.g. adding effects).
- After four minutes, a new instrument is finally introduced, but it doesn't really make the song any more worthwhile listening to. Voice samples can be used to create interesting effects that go well with the music (take e.g. this classic which is roughly in the same genre as your track - and, to add to the previous bullet point, only uses a single (!) note throughout the whole track, yet it made people rave like mad in the 90s), but in your case it's just four random notes that are in dissonance with the acid line playing at the same time. The result is very jarring.
173
Project / Coder's Corner / Re: Where can I start learning about programming a module player?
« on: April 20, 2021, 19:25:51 »
A variety of module formats is documented at https://ftp.modland.com/pub/documents/format_documentation/ - but it's important to keep in mind that often this documentation is not very formal or complete, because
- it was written by teenagers
- it was reverse-engineered and thus might be missing some details.
As MOD is a pretty popular format, there are several documents on the format with various degrees of completeness. You may want to look into this one in particular, because it's essentially a corrected version of another popular document:
https://ftp.modland.com/pub/documents/format_documentation/Protracker%20effects%20(MODFIL12.TXT)%20(.mod).txt
It's also important to keep in mind that a MOD file isn't necessarily a MOD file. By that I mean that there are several closely related variants of the format with tiny differences. For example, the original Ultimate Soundtracker format is almost identical to the "M.K." ProTracker format, with the difference that it only contains 15 instead of 31 sample slots, and doesn't contain the magic bytes ("M.K."). There are many more tiny differences beyond that, but those two would be the main reason why a SoundTracker MOD wouldn't load in a regular MOD loader. Many of these small details are not properly documented and can only be found by dissecting other loaders.
- it was written by teenagers
- it was reverse-engineered and thus might be missing some details.
As MOD is a pretty popular format, there are several documents on the format with various degrees of completeness. You may want to look into this one in particular, because it's essentially a corrected version of another popular document:
https://ftp.modland.com/pub/documents/format_documentation/Protracker%20effects%20(MODFIL12.TXT)%20(.mod).txt
It's also important to keep in mind that a MOD file isn't necessarily a MOD file. By that I mean that there are several closely related variants of the format with tiny differences. For example, the original Ultimate Soundtracker format is almost identical to the "M.K." ProTracker format, with the difference that it only contains 15 instead of 31 sample slots, and doesn't contain the magic bytes ("M.K."). There are many more tiny differences beyond that, but those two would be the main reason why a SoundTracker MOD wouldn't load in a regular MOD loader. Many of these small details are not properly documented and can only be found by dissecting other loaders.
174
The Lobby / Re: Module not uploading
« on: April 18, 2021, 19:27:53 »
You can see the upload status of pending modules at https://modarchive.org/index.php?request=members_uploads_page with a short explanation of the status. Please note that ModArchive is run by volunteers and we screen modules when we have time to do so.
175
The Lobby / Re: More pattern scrolling effects
« on: April 08, 2021, 00:08:12 »
Ranked 1st in the tracked music compo at Revision 2021. 
176
The Lobby / Re: Saying Hi - Also What of the Torrent Modules of 2020???
« on: April 06, 2021, 15:27:19 »
Welcome. The torrent will come whenever it's ready.
177
Help me find that... / Re: Anyone help me finding this particular S3M file? (Youtube upload included)
« on: April 06, 2021, 15:25:30 »
Have you tried contacting the video create on YouTube?
178
Sampling / Re: Question about samples copyright
« on: April 02, 2021, 14:30:49 »
It should sound exactly the same, that's how I exported it after all (each pattern to its own file). What kind of difference do you hear?
179
Project / Coder's Corner / Re: BRO-Tracker: Popcorn
« on: March 29, 2021, 16:23:04 »
The orignial tune is Neointro by Hannes Seifert (who designed the HSC format). Here's a more accurate rendition. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L916AcM4lhE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L916AcM4lhE
180
Help me find that... / Re: Who made this tune?
« on: March 26, 2021, 18:39:19 »
It seems to be a broken/incomplete version of the game over music from Astaroth by Mad Max: https://youtu.be/K2iSxlAMejc?t=775
The intro is missing, and the main lead uses a different instrument.
It could be a "remix" (using the term very loosely here) or a bad conversion.
Original file is here: http://files.exotica.org.uk/modland/?file=pub/modules/Hippel/Jochen%20Hippel/astaroth.hip (subsong 3)
The intro is missing, and the main lead uses a different instrument.
It could be a "remix" (using the term very loosely here) or a bad conversion.
Original file is here: http://files.exotica.org.uk/modland/?file=pub/modules/Hippel/Jochen%20Hippel/astaroth.hip (subsong 3)