hi, cs127 here, I noticed you talked about some of my tracks, and I felt like I need to clear some things up.
cs127 doesn't really need this site, but github.
no clue what you mean by that lol
epic fail, saying what should not be said. in a certain competition this will not be listened to with any program. just don't do it. "don't play in impulse tracker because..." or "if you insist playing in program must edit". why didn't the artist check song and do extension himself? he asks two patterns extended. because he thinks nobody uses impulse tracker anymore. i don't care, just don't tell people to do this and modify song. there is enough trouble as it is with misrepresentation.
come on, be realistic, who uses Impulse Tracker today?
even still, why would I care if this wouldn't be played in a competition because I told them to play it in a fairly modern tracker? I just make music for fun.
if I were to make something for a compo, of course I would try to make it as compatible as possible.
the comments in the file are just a suggestion. all of my IT songs are fully compatible with Impulse Tracker. the only reasons I suggest people to listen to it with OpenMPT, Schism, or any "modern" player are
* stereo samples, which Impulse Tracker plays as mono.
* lowpass filter, which an average user might not know they have to use an MMX driver to make it work in Impulse Tracker.
this guy only does covers anyway and i will not review anything else by him.
that is absolutely incorrect! you would know if you saw any other of my uploads.
noticed how the bass was done. but why no offset commands for left-side track?
why
should there be offsets for the left track? the point is to have the offsets be
different. it's perfectly fine for one of them to start at 0 (the left one in this case).
"play in latest version of openmpt." it does not include test builds. so this artist fails.
once again, just a suggestion.
you can play this in any IT-compatible tracker and it will play just fine, as long as you know what you're doing.
this is for the average user that doesn't know Impulse doesn't support stereo samples properly.
in fact, if I had only used mono samples, I would have put a warning in the comments for Impulse Tracker users to let them know they should use the MMX driver.
is it "unnecessary information"? to you, yes. to the average user who might not know about the compatibility of different trackers, no, it's quite helpful actually.
I probably shouldn't have taken your opinion too seriously, but like, come on... are the song comments really what you're gonna criticize? if you wanna criticize my modules, do it properly. you're better than this.
