Forest Battle Part 1 (zo-fb1.xm)

Overall Impression (8/10)

good overall song, I like the chords, the harmony is very expressive, for me this music represents a sort of desperate battle, with a sad touch.

Technique, Arrangement, Composition (7/10)

the tracking is quite simple. there is not a lot of effects or volume data. it has sometimes a little lack of expressivity because near-all notes are at the max volume (no volume info = max note volume = 64/64)

Development (6/10)

it's strange because some parts are very rich, develops very well, but others seems to be quite confusing, nearly random ! (especially the end of the song, I don't understand these strange awful-sounding chords !)

generally, the song is maybe a bit repetitive

Creativity (7/10)

interesting. it uses very-low quality samples, it sounds like a SNes music !
but the choice of the instruments are pretty good, and the ensemble doesn't sound bad. it just had a special oldschool sounding.

Enjoyment (6/10)

I've added these song to my module folder, so that means I like sometimes to re-listen to it. But I generally listen only to the first part, I don't like very much the 2nd...

Additional Comment

continue to make songs ! good luck !