karbad3 (karbad3.mod)

Overall Impression (6/10)

Energetic, fun song to hear. The compo is only a couple of minutes long, therefor it never gets boring. The thematic choices by the composer are well done.

Technique, Arrangement, Composition (5/10)

The composer is probably starting with tracking or doesn't know his way around the tracker yet. There is no real end to the song. A shame, because it is not finished. The composer has had some nice ideas, which are implemented correctly, but not worked out too much. So the song never gets going, it seems.

Development (5/10)

The melody should be better, more complex in this case, and could be great with some half-tone submelody. The same can be said from the drums, which are boring and not lively enough.

Creativity (6/10)

The effects used are limited and used in the same way. The samples are well chosen, so they blend together in the song. The transitions to the speedy parts and the easygoing melody could have some look-in-to. This kind of melody is heard to often.

Enjoyment (6/10)

Nice to start with, but not to listen to every day. It is catchy, but could be great. Too many copy and paste work. Somewhere you feel this composer has talent, but it is not directly or maybe completely found in this particular song.