Calm Runner (masternama_-_calmrunner.xm)

Overall Impression (6/10)

"Calm runner" honestly sounds like a good name for this module, Very simple and upbeat as the song continues to play. There is a nice drum pattern that I feel fits well with this chiptune.

Technique, Arrangement, Composition (5/10)

I liked how the piece gradually introduced new layers over time, Starting off with the descending pattern then adding strings and percussion. The effects used overall were very basic and rudimentary

Development (5/10)

The transitions between the main melodies from the middle to the end were pretty good despite the simplicity of said melody. There were times where I couldn't hear the main melody especially at the lower notes possibly because all the other samples were at the same volume, maybe an improvement in dynamics could help with that.

Creativity (4/10)

I feel that some of the musical patterns should have some variation as they seem not that noticeable or even there at all. I feel that this would make the piece sound more interesting to as it and help it make sound less predictable. I also wish that the piece were to be a little longer, add a slight detour then finish off.

Enjoyment (5/10)

Even tho this is a rather simple piece it does get too repetitive. It is indeed catchy but does get kinda boring after a while. Despite that the instruments were a good choice especially the percussion which actually fit well because it sounds soft (not heavy and pounding) just like with the rest of the samples used.

Additional Comment

I could see this as a soundtrack to a level in a fast-paced game or a sidescroller. If it were more developed, it may even be an OST for a game. I could see the potential of this if were to be more advanced