melon (melon.mod)

Overall Impression (4/10)

This song is catchy, but repetitive.
At first it is nice to listen to, but after a while it is getting boring, because the same lines are heard over and over again. At the end, when you think it is over but it all starts over again, it is almost getting annoying.

Technique, Arrangement, Composition (8/10)

The composer knows his way around the tracker. The samples are carefully choosen and the effects are used in an excellent way. The composition is based around one theme and the song would be much better if this theme was expended. It could be considered a bit lazy.

Development (6/10)

The begin and the end of the song are great. It starts really well and the listener is getting the feeling this could be a great song. The panning is used nicely, balanced, not too much, and the drums are done great.
The transitions, mostly done with drums, are funny and smoothly.

Creativity (5/10)

As said, this song should be shorter, could be more interesting and is in desperate need of a bigger theme and/or completer melody. The instrument, influenced by Jamaican music, which plays the melody will get on your nerves eventually.
The screamsample in pattern 2 is unnecessary and doesn't add anything to the piece of music. The melody is not that original. It's easy listening, but maybe partially lent.

Enjoyment (7/10)

The artist has put a lot of time in this song, and that you can hear. But it is not a complete piece of music. It could be better and if this artist continues his work, I am sure there will be much greater songs!